The Times 20150107.pdf

(18220 KB) Pobierz
Helpline
blunders
led to NHS
meltdown
Chris Smyth
Health Correspondent
Kat Lay
Fashion
wednesday january 7 2015 | thetimes.co.uk | no 71399
OF LONDON
The 10 fabulous must-have
items to buy now
Pages 50-51
DAVID A. AGUILAR / CFA
Untrained operators sent patients straight to A&E
doors. Suzanne Mason, professor of
emergency medicine at the University
of Sheffield, said that the numbers sent
to A&E after calling 111 was a “huge
problem” and that ambulance services
in some parts of the country had
been “brought to their knees” by call
handlers following a risk-averse
computer programme.
“There are certain times of day and
days of the week when call handlers get
to the bottom of the algorithm and look
at what services are available locally
and there isn’t anything there,” she said.
Calls to 111 doubled over the Christ-
mas period. Professor Mason added:
“The GPs have a choice: they don’t have
to open. The emergency department
doesn’t [have that choice]. One of the
things we need to look at changing is
the national availability of things like
GP services over the holiday period. It
just doesn’t make any sense for them to
close down.”
Gordon Miles, chief executive of the
College of Emergency Medicine, said:
“The data we’ve seen on NHS 111 per-
formance clearly shows that they refer
more patients to A&E at weekends.”
Nigel Edwards, chief executive of the
Nuffield Trust think-tank, said that 111
was among a series of problems that
had combined to push hospitals into a
“chaos cycle” of delays. He pointed to
problems getting GP appointments and
delays in discharging frail patients from
hospitals to provide space for people
arriving for emergency treatment.
In the week before Christmas, only
89 per cent of patients were seen within
four hours, the lowest figure on record,
and well below the government’s target
Continued on page 7, col 2
A surge in patients sent to accident
and emergency units by unqualified
call handlers was blamed last night
for helping to tip hospitals into
“meltdown”.
Operators on the non-emergency
NHS 111 helpline, who have no medical
training, were needlessly advising
callers to attend A&E in what has be-
come a “huge problem”, experts said.
Official figures show that NHS 111
sends 50 per cent more patients to A&E
at the weekend, when GPs and other
services are shut, placing a huge strain
on hospitals.
Doctors’ leaders said that nurses,
who handled calls to NHS
Direct, the previous incarnation of
the helpline, had the experience to
know when patients did not need to go
to hospital.
Under the 111 system, which was
piloted in 2010 but not introduced
fully across Britain until last year,
call handlers follow a computerised
symptom-checker that defaults to
A&E as a safety-first option. Seven
per cent of callers are currently told to
attend A&E, and an ambulance is sent
to one in ten.
The 111 warning came as it was re-
vealed that waiting times in A&E are at
their worst for a decade, with more than
400,000 people waiting longer than
four hours to be dealt with in the three
months to December.
It also emerged that at least a dozen
hospitals have declared emergencies
this week as they are too full to deal
with patients coming through the
Rock show
An artist’s impression of an Earth-like planet that has just been found orbiting close enough to its star to
support water. American scientists say that the planet could possibly sustain an environment similar to our own.
Page 8
Merkel backs migrant benefit cuts
David Charter
Berlin
Francis Elliott
Political Editor
Angela Merkel is poised to support
British plans to cut millions of pounds
of benefits sent abroad to the children
of migrants.
During an official visit to London
today, the German chancellor is
expected to tell David Cameron that
she can back any reasonable reforms to
European Union treaties provided that
they do not challenge the principle of
free movement.
The intervention will come as a boost
for the prime minister’s promise to
reform Europe prior to a referendum in
2017 on Britain’s membership. With Mr
Cameron’s ability to win a new deal for
Britain a critical issue before the
general election in May, Berlin is aware
that Mrs Merkel’s words will be scruti-
nised. Keen to avoid being dragged into
electioneering, she will be careful to
temper her support with the warning
that, as with the controversial appoint-
ment of Jean-Claude Juncker as Euro-
pean Commission president, Germany
cannot force the 26 other countries to
accept British demands.
Hopes are rising in Downing Street,
however, that Mrs Merkel will go fur-
ther than ever in backing changes to
EU treaties beyond those needed to
reform the eurozone.
Mr Cameron, Nick Clegg and Ed
Miliband have backed the idea of scrap-
ping rules that allow EU migrants to
claim benefits for children who still live
in their home country. The payouts cost
Britain about £30 million each year.
Rules around the payment of child
benefit abroad are enshrined in EU
treaties, meaning that all member
states would have to agree to alter
them. Germany is considered to hold
particular sway.
Mrs Merkel will also indicate flexibil-
ity on Mr Cameron’s demand to drop
the EU’s formal commitment to “ever
closer union”, which dates back to its
first treaty of 1957.
Again, she will underline that the
Continued on page 4, col 1
IN THE NEWS
Duke under pressure
Jeffrey Epstein controlled
dozens of under-age girls, it
has been alleged, as pictures
emerged of the Duke of York
with topless women on the
billionaire’s yacht.
Pages 10-11
Violent crime up 25% Malaria deaths soar
Violent attacks involving
wounding and grievous bodily
harm have jumped by 25 per
cent in London. The level of
common assault rose by
almost 40 per cent.
Page 14
The ebola outbreak is having a
devastating effect on malaria
treatment. Patients in west
Africa are staying away from
doctors in the belief that they
are spreading ebola.
Page 24
Bank chaos revealed
Bank of England officials
congratulated themselves on
their handling of the economy
days before Northern Rock
came close to collapse,
documents reveal.
Page 32
Referees under fire
Referees in the Premier
League have come under
attack from the former head
of match officials, who said
that some were performing
like “bungling idiots”.
Page 60
Buying The Times overseas:Austria
€4.80;
Belgium €4.00; Bulgaria BGN 7.50; Cyprus
€4.00; northern Cyprus YTL 8.00; Denmark
DKK 30; France €4.00; Germany €4.00;
Gibraltar £2.50; Greece €4.00; Italy € 4.00;
Luxembourg €4.00; Malta €4.00; Morocco
MAD 36; Netherlands €4.00; Norway NOK42;
Oman OMR1.50; Portugal €4.00 (cont.); Spain
€4.00; Sweden SEK35; Switzerland CHF6.80;
Turkey YTL6.50; UAE AED11
2
FGM
Wednesday January 7 2015
|
the times
News
INSIDE TODAY
Cameron will embrace Merkel
as his No 1 friend in Europe —
but behind the
smiles all
is not well
Opinion
The eurozone needs to invest,
not just spend, to end its
economic
misery
Andrew
Sentance,
page 41
Business
Credit card spending boom
as lenders offer better deals
Kathryn Hopkins
Economics Correspondent
Borrowed time
Percentage balance of lenders
reporting higher demand for
credit card lending
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
-10
-20
-30
-40
Roger Boyes,
page 18
Obituary
Jean-Pierre
Beltoise,
controversial
French
racing
driver
Page 45
Times2
The ice diet:
the scientific
way to keep
fit in 2015
Pages
48, 49
Opinion
17
Weather
17
Cartoon
19
Leading articles
20
Letters
21
World
24
Business
32
Markets
42, 43
Register
44
Times2
48
Sport
54
Crosswords
47, 64
Please note, some sections of The Times are available only in the United Kingdom and Ireland
© TIMES NEWSPAPERS LIMITED, 2015. Published and licensed for distribution in electronic and all other derivative forms by Times Newspapers Ltd, 1 London Bridge Street, London,
SE1 9GF, telephone 020-7782 5000. Printed by Newsprinters (Broxbourne) Limited, Great Cambridge Road, Waltham Cross, EN8 8DY and also at Newsprinters (Knowsley) Limited,
Kitling Road, Prescot, Merseyside, L34 9HN; Newsprinters (Eurocentral) Limited, Byramsmuir Road, Holytown, Motherwell, ML1 1NP; Belfast Telegraph Newspapers Ltd, 124 Royal
Avenue, Belfast, BT1 1EB; Smurfit Kappa NewsPress Ltd, Kells Industrial Estate, Kells, County Meath, Ireland; Irish Times Print Facility,4080 Kingswood Road, Citywest Business
Campus, Dublin 24, Ireland; Arab Media Group, Masar Printing and Publishing PO Box 485100, Dubai, UAE; Europrinter, Av J. Mermoz, Zone Aeropole, 6041 Gosselies, Belgium; Bermont
S.A, Av./Portugal, 4 (Centro de Transportes de Coslada), 28820 Coslada, Madrid; MOP, Zone Industrielle, Avenue De L’Europe, 13127 Vitrolles, Marseilles; Estetik Ltd, Kuscuburnu
mevkii bati beton yolu no: 4 yazibasi torbali, Izmir, Turkey; and Miller Newsprint Ltd, Miller House, Tarxien Road, Malta Airport, LQA 05 Luqa, Malta; Hellenic Miller Newsprint Ltd,
Ioanni Kranidioti Avenue 206, 2235 Latsia, PO Box 24508, 1300 Lefkosia, Cyprus; Milkro Hellas Publisher Services Ltd, 2nd Kilometer Peanias – Markopoullo Ave, Position Nisiza 19400
Koropi, Greece; Omniprint SA, Poligono Industrial, Nave Omniprint, Santa Maria Dell Cami, 7320 Mallorca.
For permission to copy articles or headlines for internal information purposes contact Newspaper Licensing Agency at PO Box 101, Tunbridge Wells, TN1 1WX, tel 01892 525274, e-mail
copy@nla.co.uk. For all other reproduction and licensing inquiries contact Syndication Department, 1 London Bridge Street, London, SE1 9GF, telephone 020-7782 5400, e-mail syndica-
tion@thetimes.co.uk
Britons’ appetite for spending on credit
cards in the three months to Christmas
rocketed to its highest level since 2007,
according to figures from the Bank of
England.
Banks and building societies are
predicting another significant increase
in demand in the first quarter of this
year, with some attributing the rise in
demand to successful marketing
campaigns and product enhancements.
At the same time as demand rose,
lenders also appeared to be more will-
ing to hand out credit cards to borrow-
ers without a good credit score.
“Credit scoring criteria loosened
significantly and the proportion of ap-
plicants being approved increased,”
said the Bank of England survey of
lenders for the final three months of last
year. “Lenders reported a significant
decline in the credit quality of new
credit card lending.”
It was not just credit cards that
households were snapping up. Demand
for other unsecured lending products,
such as personal loans, also increased
Increase
in demand
Source: Bank of England
07 08 09
10
11
12
13
2014
significantly at the end of last year to its
highest level since the survey began in
2007.
One reason for the surge in unse-
cured lending appears to be consumers’
ability to pay the money back. In the lat-
est Bank report, lenders said that de-
fault rates on credit card lending in
particular “fell significantly” in the final
three months of last year.
The data tallies with a slew of recent
figures that have shown rapid growth in
consumer credit while the housing
market continues to run out of steam.
Gillian Guy, the chief executive of
Citizens Advice, a debt charity that is
expecting to help more than 10,500
people in the first week of this month,
warned that an increase in spending on
credit cards was a sign that households
were struggling to cope.
“Many families are starting the year
in the red. Credit card debt is the second
most common debt problem brought to
Citizens Advice Bureaux,” she said.
“Demand for credit cards and unse-
cured loans at its highest point for
seven years is a warning that people are
struggling to pay everyday costs.”
The Bank’s figures showed that
demand for mortgages slipped to its
lowest level since 2008 on the back of
tougher lending conditions imple-
mented by the Financial Conduct
Authority and the Bank.
Rob Wood, chief UK economist at
Berenberg Bank, said: “While Bank of
England action slowed the housing
market in the second half of last year,
consumers geared up their spending in
the shops. Based on the central bank’s
credit conditions survey, it seems con-
sumers’ Christmas priority was buying
a new TV rather than a new house.”
Energy firms told to share oil savings
Matt Dathan, Sam Coates
of
LONDON
Feel closer to home.
Every day.
Wherever you live in the world, stay in touch every
day with The Digital Pack, just £1 for 30 days.
Our tablet edition automatically downloads every
section, every article and all the weekend supplements.
So you’ll never miss the news from home.
Try it today at timespacks.com/london
George Osborne has told energy com-
panies and airlines that they must pass
on the benefits of falling oil and gas
prices to customers.
The Treasury has begun an internal
investigation into the behaviour of
companies that depend on oil and gas.
The price of oil is about $50 (£33) a bar-
rel, the lowest since the 2008 financial
crisis, having dropped 50 per cent over
the past 12 months. Brent crude, the
global benchmark, was down $2.37 to
$50.73 a barrel.
The inquiry comes amid pressure
from some Tories to make a commit-
ment not to raise fuel duty after the
election. There is also pressure on the
Treasury to force petrol retailers to
print the amount of tax paid during
every petrol purchase on receipts is-
sued by petrol stations. The chancellor
told cabinet colleagues yesterday that
families should feel the rewards of the
drop in oil prices through cheaper bills
and flights. He added that businesses
would be “watched like hawks” to see if
they were reducing prices.
A Treasury spokesman hinted at un-
specified further action if energy com-
panies failed to pass on their reduced
costs to customers. This could include
referral to the Competition and
Markets Authority. A source pointed to
supermarkets that have dropped fuel
prices as evidence that cuts could be
passed on to customers, calling for
other industries to follow suit.
Motorists filling up at Asda will pay
105.7p a litre for petrol or 112.7p a litre
for diesel after the supermarket an-
nounced its fourteenth price cut since
the end of September, while Morrisons
and Sainsbury’s have cut prices seven
times since the beginning of December.
The RAC has predicted that petrol
prices could soon fall below £1 per litre,
their lowest since 2009.
“So far it has worked with fuel prices,”
the Treasury source said of the govern-
ment pressure on firms to pass on their
reduced costs. “Pump prices are com-
ing down; we believe it can work with
other industries.”
Downing Street said the prime min-
ister was “very keen” to see falling oil
and gas prices passed on to households.
6
The Lib Dems will confirm this week
that they are dropping Vince Cable as
their economy spokesman during the
election campaign. Danny Alexander
will take the role after performing the
job of chief secretary to the Treasury for
almost five years.
Scots hit by oil price collapse, page 15
Blair’s tax bill falls despite
Boris attacks
company turnover of £14m
‘multi-culti
Nadeem Badshah
THE DIGITAL PACK £1 FOR 30 DAYS
Offer subject to availability, £1 for 30 days trial to new customers (18+) of the Digital Pack only. TNL reserves right to exclude this offer in certain territories.
See timespacks.com/london for full terms and conditions.
A company set up by Tony Blair to
handle his business interests halved its
corporation tax bill to less than
£300,000 despite generating turnover
of £14 million, according to the latest
accounts.
The figures for Windrush Ventures
showed that nearly £13 million was
written off as “administrative expenses”
and more than £5 million was held in
cash by the firm.
It is believed that the expenses cover
hotels and flights for his staff as well as
for the former prime minister’s own
travel, including his private jet, dubbed
Blair Force One.
Windrush Ventures, which is among
a network of companies set up by Mr
Blair to manage his business affairs,
reported a fall in profits from £2.8 mil-
lion in 2013 to £1.2 million last year.
Turnover fell from £14.9 million in
2013 to £14.2 million.
The expenses claims allowed the
company to offset its income and re-
duce his corporate tax bill from
£693,000 in 2013 to £293,000 last year.
Mr Blair, the company’s sole share-
holder, also benefited from a cut in
Britain’s corporation tax rate.
In a statement on the Office of
Tony Blair website, the organisation
insisted that no conclusions should
be drawn from the accounts published.
“The financial results released today
do not represent the overall profits of
either of the Windrush or Firerush
businesses.
“Instead they present the operating
costs of the businesses, and additional
sums that may be held back in corpo-
rate reserves for investment in future.”
It added: “Mr Blair is a UK taxpayer
and pays full personal tax on all his
earnings worldwide.”
In December a spokesman for Mr
Blair disclosed that the former prime
minister’s “net worth is roughly equal to
what he has given away”.
Vanity Fair
reported that since quitting Downing
Street Mr Blair has given $15 million, or
just under £10 million, to good causes.
bonkerisation’
Laura Pitel
Political Correspondent
Councils must stop the “multi-culti”
practice of translating leaflets into
other languages, Boris Johnson said.
The mayor of London said that he
was “amazed” to read that some people
could not make themselves understood
to doctors and nurses and called on all
migrants to learn English.
He said that Britain went through a
long period of “multi-culti bonkerisa-
tion of our society”, with school-
children taught in their native tongues
and council literature translated into
“umpteen languages”.
His remarks came after the Ukip
leader, Nigel Farage, said that he would
fire NHS doctors with poor English.
Speaking on LBC radio, the mayor
said that he “passionately” agreed with
a caller who said he shared Mr Farage’s
view. “I think everybody in this country,
particularly people working in public
services, should speak English,” he said.
the times
|
Wednesday January 7 2015
FGM
3
Stephen Fry’s
secret is out
as wedding
is revealed . . .
Kaya Burgess
News
JABPROMOTIONS / REX
Stephen Fry once wrote that loneliness
was his “most terrible problem” and
said that he needed “saving” from more
than a decade of self-imposed celibacy.
It seems he has been.
The 57-year-old actor and presenter
has found love with a man 30 years his
junior and yesterday confirmed that
they will marry later this year.
Two days before Christmas, the
Blackadder
star and
QI
presenter gave
formal notice with his fiancé Elliott
Spencer,27, a writer and comedian, at a
register office in Dereham, Norfolk, not
far from where Fry grew up.
After the news emerged yesterday,
Fry tweeted: “Oh. It looks as though a
certain cat is out of a certain bag. I’m
very, very happy of course but had
hoped for a private wedding. Fat
chance!”
After a flood of positive responses, he
added: “Thank you all SO much for
your kind congratulations. Deeply
touched xxx.”
Speaking from the family home in
Swanwick, Hampshire, Mr Spencer’s
father, Robert Spencer — who is the
same age as his future son-in-law —
said: “We are very happy for them both.
We’ve known for a while. I wouldn’t like
to say much more, but it will be within
the next year.”
He separately told the
Daily Mail
that
he and his wife Melinda, 52, were “over
the moon”. Documents on display in
the register office state that the wed-
ding will take place in Breckland Busi-
ness Centre in Dereham.
Fry has spoken in the past about his
battle with depression and struggles
with loneliness. He has also revealed
that he tried to commit suicide in 2012. A
friend of the comedian told
The Sun:
“Since Stephen met Elliott it is like he
has a new lust for life. We’ve got the old
Stephen back.”
Hugh Laurie, who enjoyed an
acclaimed comedic partnership with
Fry, tweeted a tribute. The duo often re-
ferred to each other as “m’col” or
“m’colleague”, and Laurie tweeted:
“Huge congratulations to m’col and
h’col. Love and happiness. Looking for-
ward to magnificent Venetian revels.”
Another friend told
The Sun:
“Since
Stephen met Elliott it is like he has a
new lust for life. We’ve got the old
Stephen back. He has spoken about his
problems in the past because he wants
others suffering with depression and
loneliness to know it can affect every-
one. But he has found new hope in
Elliott and they thrive off one another.”
It is believed that the pair became a
couple last summer. Mr Spencer posted
a photo of them with the actress Emma
Thompson in Florence in late August,
and the pair have exchanged public
tweets on Twitter, where Fry has more
than 8.3 million followers.
A spokesman for the presenter said:
Stephen Fry with his fiancé Elliott Spencer a writer and comedian. Mr Spencer’s parents said that they were over the moon
“Stephen Fry is very happy and proud
to say that he has set the wheels in
motion for a wedding sometime in the
future but no date has been set due to a
busy work schedule.”
In 2010 Fry split from his partner
Daniel Cohen, a make-up salesman,
after a 14-year-relationship before
which, his website recounts, he had
Stephen Fry’s Tweet
Oh. It looks as though a certain
cat is out of a certain bag. I’m
very very happy of course but
had hoped for a private
wedding. Fat chance!
a “marathon 16-year spell of sexual
abstinence”.
The comedian was later in a relation-
ship with Stephen Webb, an actor, but
appeared to be single in 2013 when he
wrote in a frank blog post: “Loneliness
is the most terrible and contradictory of
my problems. I hate having only myself
to come home to.”
. . . while Cameron Diaz marries without even the neighbours knowing
Rhys Blakely
Los Angeles
Cameron Diaz, the Hollywood actress,
has married Benji Madden, a musician,
in a ceremony that the couple kept
secret by telling neighbours it was a
party to mark this Sunday’s Golden
Globe awards.
Diaz, 42, and Madden, 35, who plays
in the bands
The Madden Brothers
and
Good Charlotte,
were married at their
home in Beverly Hills.
The ceremony was
attended by 90 guests,
including Reese With-
erspoon,
Gwyneth
Paltrow and Nicole
Richie, with Drew
Cameron Diaz
and Benji
Madden
Barrymore as a brides-
maid.
The couple began
dating last May and be-
came engaged just
before
Christmas.
“We couldn’t be
happier
to
begin our
new jour-
ney
to-
gether surrounded by our closest
family and friends,” they said in a state-
ment. The event was organised by Yifat
Oren, a celebrity wedding planner
whose clients have included Anne
Hathaway and Natalie Portman.
Stealthy weddings are a new trend. In
August Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt
married in a secret ceremony in France.
Diaz, whose in the past was romanti-
cally linked to the musicians Justin
Timberlake and Jared Leto, rose to
prominence in 1994 film
The Mask.
Her
other hits include
There’s Something
about Mary
and
Charlie’s Angels.
In 2013
she earned $42 million.
Diaz has never felt under pressure to
marry. “The big misconception in our
society is that we’re supposed to meet
[the one] when we’re 18 and . . . get mar-
ried to them and love them for the rest
of our lives,” she said in 2010.
4
FGM
Wednesday January 7 2015
|
the times
Tories will win
next election . . .
but only just,
predicts bank
Michael Savage, Francis Elliott
News
PETER BYRNE / PA
The Times
iPad edition
Owners of an iPad can
subscribe to
The Times
iPad edition through the
App Store on the device
The Conservatives will emerge victori-
ous from the most uncertain election
for a century, a leading investment
bank has predicted.
Goldman Sachs said that the Tories
were “marginally more likely” to be the
biggest party when the votes had been
counted, but forecast that David
Cameron would not have an overall
majority.
It compared the race with the 1992
election, when the “unusually wide gap
between the Conservatives and Labour
in terms of perceived economic compe-
tence” led to a Tory win.
Should the analysis prove correct,
the party would have to form another
coalition or attempt to rule as a minor-
ity government. Senior Conservatives
Exclusive to members
Opinion Podcast
General election special
On tablet and at blogs.thetimes.co.uk
admit that preparations are under way
for a second election following an
inconclusive result in May. One said
that a dedicated unit had been set up in
party headquarters to prepare for a re-
run, and that donors were being asked
to dig deep.
The bank said that the Tories would
be likely to outperform their present
showing in opinion polls because Ukip’s
share of the vote would fall as the elect-
ion approached. It also predicted strong
growth in personal incomes this year,
which could help Mr Cameron to
victory.
“The likelihood of any party gaining
an overall majority appears low, but we
think the Conservative party is margin-
ally more likely than Labour to win the
most seats and lead the next govern-
ment,” Goldman Sachs said in a
research note written by Kevin Daly, its
chief UK economist.
“Given the demographic profile and
past voting record of the majority of
Ukip voters, these votes appear more
likely to shift towards the Conserva-
tives than to Labour.”
Some of Goldman’s past estimates
have been remarkably accurate. It sug-
gested that Team GB would win a
record haul of 30 golds and 65 medals at
the London Olympics in 2012. The
team secured 29 golds and 65 medals.
However, Mr Miliband may take
some comfort from the bank’s predic-
tion that last year’s football World Cup
would be won by Brazil. In the event,
the hosts were dumped out of the tour-
nament in humiliating style, losing 7-1
to Germany, the eventual winners, in
the semi-finals.
Mr Daly said that the election voting
system favoured Labour, and Ed Mili-
band could win if he performed well
during the campaign’s televised leader-
ship debates. However, many in West-
minster now believe that the debates,
first held during the 2010 election,
would not take place this time.
The polls have narrowed over the
past year, but Labour still hold a small
lead in most. The latest YouGov poll
gave Mr Miliband a three-point lead.
Mr Daly’s analysis said that doubts
over Labour’s economic competence
had previously had the effect of “skew-
ing the final outcome relative to opin-
ion polling prior to the official vote”.
His prediction contained a warning
to the prime minister that should he
lead the next government, attention
was “likely to turn quickly to the refer-
endum on EU membership that David
Cameron has committed to hold”. The
research note added: “We have argued
that a UK exit from the EU would be
costly, but is still unlikely.”
Tories act to scrap law
Tory MPs are trying to enlist the
chairman of the 1922 Committee
of backbenchers to scrap the
Fixed-term Parliaments Act.
Graham Brady has been
approached by colleagues urging
him to convey the scale of
disquiet about the act, which
removed the power to call an
election. Senior Tories believe it
be abandoned after the election if
there is an unstable coalition.
Sex attackers cautioned
Sex attackers and violent
offenders are still being given
cautions by the police instead of
being taken to court, the
chairman of the Magistrates’
Association said. Richard
Monkhouse said that even people
selling drugs near schools were
being handed cautions. He told
MPs that between 20 and 30 per
cent of cases were settled outside
the courts inappropriately.
Military chapel rescued
The Battle of Britain chapel,
which is to lose its public funding,
has been rescued by a local
aerodrome. Biggin Hill airport
will provide £50,000 a year to
maintain St George’s Chapel of
Remembrance, which was built
in 1951 with Winston Churchill’s
support to celebrate the war
efforts of Battle of Britain pilots.
A petition against its closure has
25,000 signatures.
Walking tall
Zahra, the two-week-old rare baby Rothschild Giraffe, takes her first
steps outside at Chester Zoo with her mother, Aoife. Only 1,100 remain in the wild
Merkel set to give Cameron a boost
The lure of
by backing cuts in migrant benefits
past triumphs
Continued from page 1
Wet walkers complain
Scores of pedestrians have
complained to police after being
splashed when motorists drove
through puddles. Police forces
across England and Wales have
been contacted by people saying
that drivers got them wet
deliberately. There were 63
reported incidents of motorists
splashing pedestrians over five
years. Splashing can be punished
with a fixed penalty notice.
resistance to change will lie in other EU
countries reluctant to re-open the
treaties, notably France where
President Hollande is determined to
avoid any change that could lead to a
referendum.
A joint statement issued in advance
of today’s visit emphasised the two
countries’ shared objective of a more
business-friendly EU and — using lan-
guage that echoes Conservative elect-
ion slogans — called for continued
action to rein in public spending. “We
have both taken steps at home to con-
solidate our public finances and it is im-
portant that we continue to pursue this
long-term plan,” it read.
Mrs Merkel will not be meeting Ed
Miliband, the Labour leader, today. The
party blamed the government for fail-
ing to alert it to her visit, but the con-
ventional obligation only covers state
visits. Pat McFadden, Labour’s Europe
spokesman, said that in private Mrs
Merkel would warn Mr Cameron of the
limits of German influence.
“Her message will be ‘Germany can’t
bail out the periphery of Europe finan-
cially and Britain politically. You have
to show some leadership,’” he said.
Mrs Merkel is visiting Britain at the
start of a tour of the world’s largest eco-
nomies. She is taking over from Mr
Cameron the presidency of the group
now known as the G7, after Russia was
expelled from the G8 in response to its
annexation of Crimea last year.
Mr Hollande is reportedly calling for
a softening of sanctions against Russia
to reflect the damage already being
caused by falling oil prices. However,
Mrs Merkel and Mr Cameron are
expected to insist that the pressure
must remain on the Russian president
to curb pro-Moscow separatists in
Ukraine.
Mrs Merkel and Mr Cameron will
discuss an economic package to prop
up the Kiev regime from the Inter-
national Monetary Fund, expected to
be agreed within weeks. The prospect
of victory for anti-austerity parties in
Greek elections this month will lead
discussions over the world economy.
Berlin has denied that Mrs Merkel is
preparing to abandon efforts to keep
Greece in the eurozone.
Merkel under fire, page 27
David Charter
Angela Merkel’s decision to visit Britain
first on her tour of G7 countries owes as
much to an exhibition as geopolitics.
Germany: Memories of a Nation,
the
British Museum’s epic round-up of
the past 600 years of the country’s
history and culture through a collec-
tion of objects, closes on January 25.
The German chancellor has been
listening to the accompanying
Radio 4 programmes presented by the
museum’s director, Neil MacGregor,
and was keen not to miss it. She and Mr
Cameron will tour exhibits that include
a Gutenberg printing press, Meissen
porcelain and a VW Beetle.
Mrs Merkel met Mr MacGregor
when he met the culture minister in
Berlin, fuelling speculation that he was
being wooed to head the Humboldt-
Forum, a new arts complex in Berlin.
Most read at
thetimes.co.uk
1
Thousands take to streets as
Europe wrestles with identity
2
Prince Andrew and sex claims
3
Mansion tax to pay for
Scottish nurses
4
Voters don’t want nasty parties
5
Exasperated duchess
6
Greek euro exit is more likely
7
A&E targets missed
8
Leading article: Hospital Pass
9
Man v Fat
10
N Korea nuclear threat grows
the times
|
Wednesday January 7 2015
FGM
5
Vindictive accuser
should be named,
says rape claim MP
Laura Pitel
Political Correspondent
Frances Gibb
Legal Editor
News
LORNE CAMPBELL / GUZELIAN
A Conservative MP has reignited the
debate over anonymity rules in sexual
assault cases after police dropped a
rape inquiry against him.
Mark Pritchard, who represents the
Wrekin, claimed that his accuser had
concocted a “vindictive and outra-
geous” story about him and called for a
review of the law.
The MP sparked further controversy
by revealing details about the woman
who made a complaint against him.
One criminal lawyer warned that
Mr Pritchard may have breached his
accuser’s anonymity by providing
details of how he knew her and her age.
Mr Pritchard, 48, was arrested last
month after an alleged incident in
central London. He was released on
bail to return yesterday, when he was
informed that he would face no further
action due to “insufficient evidence”.
The MP, who divorced his wife of 15
years in 2013, described the episode as a
“testing time”. He said: “Sadly, as an MP,
sometimes you have a target on your
back. Of course, she remains ano-
nymous. The law on anonymity does
need to be reviewed and fairness does
need to play a far greater role in these
cases.”
His call was echoed by Nigel Evans,
the former Commons deputy speaker
who was cleared of nine sexual
assault accusations after a five-
week trial last year. He said:
“The time has come to redress
the balance to get anonymity for
both alleged victim and the
accused, at least until there is a
charge.”
Under British law,
people who claim to
be victims of sexual
offences are auto-
matically granted
Mark Pritchard:
police dropped
rape inquiry
the right to lifelong anonymity. The
alleged perpetrators can be publicly
named from the outset.
The government announced plans to
extend anonymity to defendants in
rape cases in 2010 but later abandoned
the move in the face of strong criticism.
Opponents of the change argued that
anonymity for the accused would
remove the prospect of other victims
coming forward after seeing publicity.
David Cameron yesterday rejected
calls to re-examine the issue. “It’s some-
thing we’ve looked at in the past, and
there are some real issues with it,” the
prime minister said.
Last night a women’s rights group
accused Mr Pritchard of “abusing his
power” by providing details of his
complainant in a press statement
delivered outside parliament. “There is
absolutely no justification for him
revealing this information about her,”
Alex Brew, a spokeswoman for Women
Against Rape, said. She added that his
remarks risked deterring other victims
from coming forward for fear that they
would be identified.
Legal experts were divided on the
MP’s comments. Simon McKay, a solic-
itor advocate at McKay Law, said that
he may have committed an offence
under the Sexual Offences (Amend-
ment) Act 1992 by “identifying charac-
teristics of a complainant such that
some members of the public may be
able to identify him or her”.
Mark Stephens, head of media
litigation with Howard Kennedy,
said that he did not believe the
MP had broken the law because
CPS guidance on naming victims
related only to court proceedings.
He said: “It does not say an
individual cannot tell
another individual or
a group, which is
arguably a flaw.”
Mr Pritchard said
last night: “My
comments were
checked over by
my legal team.”
Rhubarb rhubarb
Neil Hulme, whose family have grown the popular pudding plant since the 1900s, picks the first of the
season’s indoor crop. Grown in total darkness, it is harvested by candlelight to avoid turning the sticks green and tough
Consultant ‘assaulted girl
after performing abortion’
Fiona Hamilton
Crime Correspondent
A retired doctor at Stoke Mandeville
hospital performed a back street abor-
tion on a 16-year-old former patient
before raping her immediately after-
wards, a court heard yesterday.
Michael Salmon, a former consultant
paediatrician, is accused of carrying out
sexual abuse at the Buckinghamshire
hospital at the same time the disgraced
BBC presenter Jimmy Savile was
assaulting patients, although prosecu-
tors said there was no connection
between the cases.
The 79-year-old is accused of three
counts of rape, 11 of indecent assault
and two of using an instrument with in-
tent to procure a miscarriage.
Reading crown court was told yester-
day that the charges relate to eight girls,
aged from 11 to 18, who were allegedly
attacked between 1973 and 1988.
Mr Salmon is no longer a doctor,
the jury was told, having been struck
off the medical register in 1991 after
being convicted of three counts of
indecent assault against young female
patients.
Miranda Moore, QC, opening the
case for the prosecution, said that Mr
Salmon allegedly examined and as-
saulted young girls in a room screened
off from their parents, believing that he
was “bomb-proof” because no one
would believe a child over him.
Ms Moore said that most of the 16
counts were of a very similar nature.
“In one case he used a girl’s distress to
offer to undertake an illegal abortion,
and raped her in the aftermath, at the
same time.”
That case refers to a teenage girl who
had been referred to him a year earlier
over a digestive system problem. The
jury heard that she then became preg-
nant in 1984 and went to Mr Salmon,
who allegedly performed a backstreet
abortion. He is accused of raping her
while she screamed out in pain.
Mr Salmon, who lives with his wife
Mary in Salisbury, Wiltshire, denies
any wrongdoing. The trial is expected
to last four weeks.
Zgłoś jeśli naruszono regulamin